Next: .
Up: Mathematics the
Previous: Mathematics the
Marxism provides a coherent understanding of the
philosophy of science.
According to the materialist view all our ideas come not from heaven or
some special realm of
thoughts but from the world we live in. This is as true of science as it
is of religion or anything
else. Marx's view was more subtle than that of deterministic materialism
in that he saw how our
ideas did not simply reflect the real world passively, but that they could
consciously shape our
environment in order to satisfy our needs.
Science, however, is different to other forms of thought because, in
contrast to religion, it can
discover and make sense of the way the world behaves. Newton's theory of
gravitation, for example,
was not just an idea in Newton's mind -- it contained at least a partial
truth that allowed humans to
explain and control a whole range of phenomena, from the falling of apples
to the motion
of planets. Science is not a fixed methodology but a developing process,
nevertheless two prominent
features can be identified:
- scientific ideas are
not to be taken on trust,
but are open to rational disagreement and debate
- scientific theories
must be tested in
practice, modified and corrected where necessary.
Of
course this scientific ideal
is rarely matched by reality, but there is a strong contrast between the
scientific method and the
way religious ideas are developed. With religion there is an emphasis on
faith -- i.e. the
unquestioning acceptance of dogma. Many of the ideas cannot be tested in
practice (how can you tell
whether you go to heaven when you die?) and those religious ideas which can
be tested usually fail
that test (the world was not made in seven days!) The two features of
scientific thought (above)
help to explain the enormous advance that science made over its
predecessors. It has been a vital
ingredient in a process that has extended the understanding and control of
humans over every aspect
of our environment.
Next: .
Up: Mathematics the
Previous: Mathematics the
Robin HIRSCH
2001-04-30